By Suzanne Sparrow Watson

MCC library

Wright’s Great Library

One of the best jobs I ever held was as a tour guide at the Marin County Civic Center back in the mid-1960’s.  The iconic building was the last of Frank Lloyd Wright’s masterpieces.  In fact, when I worked there only the Administration building was completed but we were awed by the scale model of what was to come – a judicial wing, an arts building and a heliport (which was never built).  Still, as I led tour after tour on the weekends my appreciation for his architecture grew.  In my opinion, no part of the building was more stunning than the library, with its rounded ceiling and open spaces.  I was fortunate enough to develop a love of books from a grammar school teacher who spent a whole year teaching us how to read a book.  She introduced me to Nancy Drew, Tom Sawyer and Louisa May Alcott.  So, oftentimes on the weekend when my fellow tour guide and I didn’t feel like leading a tour, we’d put a sign on the desk saying we were out touring and would return in 30 minutes.  And then we would sneak off to the library.


Part of my beloved library

Over the years, whether I was in a studio apartment or a larger home, I always maintained a library.  To this day I have some of my college textbooks, which come in handy when I want to learn something about ancient history!  In my current house we converted what the architect considered a necessity, a fourth bathroom, into something I considered an absolute must – a library.  I even organized it by subject matter and author.  I know, I’m a geek.  So, when the eBook revolution came about I was one of those who swore I would never convert.  I scoffed at those who jumped on the bandwagon, even as I lugged my huge canvas bag of books on every vacation.  I think it was on one of those trips when my husband commented about the “rock collection” I’d brought along, that I began considering an eReader.  In 2010 I relented and bought my first Kindle.  I’m now on my fourth.  I love that I can store hundreds of books, that I can read at night with the light off so as not to bother my husband or Dash the Wonder Dog, and it has kept me amused as I’ve waited at doctor’s offices, airports and the DMV.


There’s room for both!

So it was with some interest that I read an article in Inc. Magazine recently noting that according to The Wall Street Journal, sales of traditional print books rose by 5 percent in the US last year, while sales of eBooks plunged by 17 percent.  No one knows exactly why that happened or if it’s a lasting trend.  They do cite two very good reasons for the switch.  First, real books can be shared.  Remember the days when we paid $20 for a book and then passed it around to 10 friends?  Now everyone has to pay around $13 for their own download.  The second reason they cited is that real books make more meaningful gifts.  I couldn’t agree more.  I still remember who gave me books as gifts and the sentiment behind the purchase.  I also love a hardcover when I’m reading one of my historical biographies with a complicated family tree illustration just so I can easily flip to the chart when I can’t remember who’s married to whom.

Those are indeed good reasons to buy a real book, but last night I discovered perhaps the best reason.  A week ago my daily email from Kindle advertised a novel about women in WWII.  Always a sucker for a good war book, I decided to download it.  Amazon informed that I already owned it.  So I went to my archives and, indeed, I bought it in 2013.  I downloaded it to my current device and began reading.  It wasn’t until last night, one third through the book, that I realized I’ve read it before.  Hey, I’m not beating myself up.  I can’t remember what I had for dinner last night, much less a book I read six years ago.  But thinking about this post today I realized that perhaps the best reason for a real book is that after you’ve read it there are creases in the spine or perhaps a dog-eared page or two, alerting you that you’ve been down that path before.  On the upside, re-reading a good book is kind of like meeting an old friend.  I guess there are benefits to losing your memory!

7 comments on “THE BOOK BATTLE

  1. I am NOT a reader I think because my elementary school teacher kept telling my mother what a bad comprehender reader I was. The criticism stuck though somehow I was able to get through college with an accounting degree. Caroline (our daughter) and Cap are the avid readers in the family. We have moved boxes of books from CA to IL to CA to TX. I finally just had Caroline go through her childhood book collection and pick out the ones that are most precious to her. I took the rest to Half Price Books (a most incredible store that even peaked my antibook interest) Of course you get pennies on the dollar like a bankruptcy! Cap still likes a hard back book. For some reason I could not part with the Nancy Drew books as I think I might have read them when I was young. Found that box with them a few days ago and decided it was time to let go! Just sold today on our local Online yard sale 13 books for $10. Probably could have gotten $20 but I know they went to a good home. Even had a second buyer for them. Way to go Nancy Drew popular 50 years later! That is my boring story!

    • Sharon – sorry for taking so long to respond. Forgot to look on “Comments”! Anyway, your story just reinforces how important a good teacher can be and how influential a bad one is. I love my books and I give full credit to my 5th grade teacher for taking me under her wing and showing me how to enjoy reading. I’m with you on getting rid of things – I’ve decided that if I’ve enjoyed something then maybe its time for someone else to enjoy them too.

      Anyway – hope all is well in Texas. Stay warm!

  2. Hi Suzanne! You will recall that your first BFF was THE most avid reader! When she passed, I filled one dozen banker’s boxes with only her bedroom library.
    Leslie was like you, and did not succumb to a Kindle purchase until you did. She loved playing games on it.
    I have three Kindles of varying sizes/abilities. I have to read books via these, due to diminishing eyesight (glaucoma, AMD, cataracts). I can make the font REALLY large!
    I keep my laptops at 125%.
    I DO miss actual hardbacks, and keep my bookmarks just in case!
    I miss Leslie much more, of course. She was one of a kind.
    I really enjoy reading your and Bob’s blogs.
    I just thought I’d address the font issue and my sister, who would have turned 69 on 2/1. Keep writing! K

    • Kathy – I did receive this response but wanted to wait until to day to get back to you. A special day, indeed. Can’t believe she’s been gone over four years. Today is hard for me as I don’t get to make the annual birthday call and I can’t imagine how hard it must be for you. But what wonderful memories we have of her! And, yes, she was a great influence on my reading since she would bury her nose in a book and not acknowledge me at times…forced me to be a reader too!!! ; )

      Hope all is well with you, little Sis.

  3. First. We need to see the Marin County Civic Center – huge fans of Frank Lloyd Wright. In Bartlesville OK, I practiced psychology in the amazing Price Tower which he designed. We also lived in a Bruce Goff home…one of his protégés. It was two floors and they all opened up to just one room each floor – excluding bathrooms! There was a big fountain and koy pond right in front of the pool in the backyard. Loved it!
    I received a Kindle as a gift but never used it.
    Still a hardcover fan – and we always have a library!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.